PREVIEW-Online brokerage profits get fleeting boost
* Short-term outlook seen weak, long-term outlook improves* Firms begin reporting next weekBy John McCrankOct 14 (Reuters) - As U.S. stock markets plunged this
summer, one group of companies made hay: retail brokerages.With trading volumes soaring, per-share earnings for
companies such as TD Ameritrade Holding Corp could
rise 55 percent, according to the average forecast from Thomson
Reuters I/B/E/S.The companies that should perform best are those that rely
most on trading revenue, said Michael Wong, an analyst at
Morningstar in Chicago.TD Ameritrade, where last quarter trading revenue made up
around 40 percent over overall revenue, would likely fare
better than a company such as Charles Schwab Corp ,
where trading revenue is around 20 percent, Wong said.E*Trade Financial Corp , like TD Ameritrade, is
also likely to turn in a strong performance because of its
heavy exposure to trading, said Joel Jeffrey, analyst Keefe,
Bruyette & Woods in New York.Schwab kicks off the earnings period for the retail
brokerages on Monday, followed by E*Trade and Raymond James
Financial Inc on Wednesday. TD Ameritrade reports the
following week, while Stifel has yet to announce a date for its
earnings release.Strong results for brokers would stand in stark contrast to
institutional broker-dealers such as Goldman Sachs Group Inc , whose results were likely hurt by market drops.
JPMorgan Chase & Co said on Thursday investment banking
fees fell 31 percent. Its trading revenue rose because of an
accounting quirk.Markets were riled in the quarter ended Sept. 30. Political
gridlock over raising the U.S. borrowing limit pushed the
United States to the brink of a debt default, the U.S. credit
rating was downgraded and the sovereign debt crisis in Europe
threatened to send the global economy back into recession.In August, that turmoil prompted TD Ameritrade’s clients to
make an average of 484,000 trades per day, well above the usual
380,000 to 400,000 range for that time of year.”Four of our top five trading days in our history were in
that month,” TD Ameritrade Chief Executive Fred Tomczyk said at
the Reuters Global Wealth Management Summit in New York in
early October. “One day we were just under 900,000 trades.”SHORT-TERM PAIN, LONG-TERM GAINWhile trade volume was strong over the course of the third
quarter, the two other main revenue sources for retail brokers
— fees on assets and interest revenue on client cash — likely
suffered as interest rates and markets fell, said Ed Ditmire,
an analyst at Macquarie Research in New York.”Overall, two of the three important revenue generators for
the brokers were working against them and continue to do so
into the fourth quarter,” he said.The near-zero interest rate environment has led some retail
brokerages to waive fees on money market funds, which has cost
hundreds of millions of dollars.It has also put a big dent in their share prices. A 14
percent drop in U.S. equities in the third quarter, as measured
by the S&P 500 index, added to the pain.Schwab’s stock fell over 31 percent in the quarter, while
TD Ameritrade was down nearly 25 percent, E*Trade around 34
percent. Raymond James and Stifel, full-service firms with
large retail brokerage units, were down around 19 percent and
26 percent, respectively.A meaningful increase in interest rates, not expected any
time soon, would be a boon to retail brokerages, especially
asset managers such as Schwab, Wong said.As of Oct. 14, analysts polled by Thomson Reuters I/B/E/S
were expecting Schwab to have earned 19 cents a share, up from
10 cents a share a year earlier.TD Ameritrade is expected to earn 31 cents a share in its
fiscal fourth quarter, compared with 20 cents, and E*Trade is
forecast to earn 18 cents a share, compared with 3 cents.Raymond James and Stifel are forecast to earn 55 cents a
share and 43 cents a share, compared with 55 cents and 48
cents, respectively.